Labels, Labels, Labels

Do any of you have any info on Expressive-Receptive Language Disorder?

We received Eli's neuropsych report back and, in addition to a few other things, this is one of the disorders that he's been diagnosed with. Apparently it's not normal for a child to be able to remember every minute detail of something that happened when he was two or be able to use the words impeccable, delectable, or persevere correctly in a sentence but NOT be able to find the words to describe a purple circle or know the opposite for the word stop or no.

I guess that would be considered a bit odd.

Asperger's was ruled out - yeah! Although they were quick to point out that there were many similarities and that they could easily give him the diagnosis if he needed it.

Uh, thanks, but no thanks.

Also, one of the things that disappointed me is that they gave Eli an IQ test. Well, if you have a language disorder or a learning disability, how can you test accurately? Eli scored in the low IQ range - and, therefore, was also diagnosed with a Cognitive Disorder.

Everyone knows that's just a PC way of saying "mentally retarded".

And I'm so glad they don't call it that anymore because it makes me cringe to hear it. My biggest pet peeve is when people say "Oh, that's so retarded" or "Don't be retarded." Ugh. If I ever suddenly smack you upside the head, it's most likely because you let that word slip out in conversation.

But, the truth is, it DOES have negative connotations and to be told that Eli is MR - or Cognitively Disabled - geez, that's just mind boggling. It's crap is what it is.

I refuse to let my mind go there. He's such a smart kid. He just learns differently.

Oh, and they also think he has dysgraphia. And some other things. I don't know. I've got a lot of research to do.

But here's the thing. In 20 years is it really going to matter if you can't write correctly? Won't everything be done on a keyboard anyway? Who cares if math is hard. That's why God invented the calculator. And if you can't remember something automatically... hello! G-O-O-G-L-E.

But to put him in an MR range and give him that diagnosis because he can't test the way other 5 year olds do? That's just plain nonsense.

Okay, okay. I DID want the neuropsych done. And now I'm complaining about what it said. It's kind of hypocritical isn't it?

I'm angry because it shows me how the system works. If you can't complete a standard IQ test then you must be dumb. A slow learner. But it takes NO consideration that not every child learns the same. I took some of those same IQ questions and reworded them for Eli and he answered every one of them. But because he couldn't answer it they way the test had it worded... well, then he's got a low IQ.

That's what frustrates me. It is so ridiculous! The kid can tell you every continent. Knows the capital of Ethiopia. Can name half the unpronounceable villages in Wales... but has a low IQ?

Puh-leeze.

Yes, learning is going to be hard for him. He's going to require a lot of hands-on learning. He learns and retains from having actual, real-life experiences. It IS going to be a challenge. Math will be a challenge. Reading will be a challenge. Writing will be a challenge. Memory retention will be a challenge. We're going to have to be really creative with his learning and his education....

But I would bet my life - and it's that whole Mother's instinct thing - that this kid is going to prove them wrong. I can feel it in my bones. In my soul. In everything I have. This label does not mean anything. It's hogwash. A bunch of phooey. Nonsense.

Will it be hard? Yeah, definitely. Impossible, no.

So there you have it. On one hand, I'm angry about it. But on the other hand, relieved. In a weird way it's good to put a name to it because it gives us a starting point. We have a better idea of how Eli learns now and we also know that some things are just really difficult for him. I used to think he was being lazy or just pulling my leg when he would say that he couldn't dress himself. Now I know that it's really hard for him to coordinate himself correctly. It would frustrate me when he would get dressed and his entire outfit would be on inside out and backwards. But knowing that maybe there's something neurologically going on helps me to be more patient with him... and to help him through it.

Now that we know what's going on, we can help him learn the way HE learns. The way HE learns best. Not the way some textbook says he has to learn or the way a bunch of professionals have deemed the most appropriate way to learn. But the way HE learns.

So if anyone has any suggestions or websites or blogs that you can point me to... well, point away, please.

And if anyone knows of a school likes THIS ONE that exists in Texas and will not require me to sell a kidney or prostitute myself in order to pay for tuition, I'd be much obliged.

Or if anyone wants to help start a school..... now that would be really cool.

Comments

sandwichinwi said…
Oh, Leslie, here's some hugs.... one for you and one for Eli.

Now take the diagnoses and suck every ounce of usefulness out of them and toss all the negative. Free services? If they're helpful, take them! Discrimination and naysayers? Avoid that activity/institution like the the plague.

I sure don't think he is MR/CD (I love how saying MR "avoids" the politically incorrect retarded word) based on what you've described. I don't know what dysgraphia is.

I think a creative mama like you will come up with all sorts of neat ways to address his strengths. Hooray that you can homeschool!

NO idea if this helps his dressing issues, but when RoseBud was little, I had to sew a "BELLY" button onto her unders so she could get them on right.

She is a total auditory learner. Banana Boy learns so much with movies and music. He's learned his whole AWANA book this semester by singing his verses.

I love to think up creative ways to learn stuff. Email me if you get stuck and want some help brainstorming. (or barnstorming--I always thought that looked like fun)

Blessings,
sandwich
Amy said…
Oh Leslie- you are so right- there is NO WAY Eli is "mentally retarded". NO WAY. And just remember he is still the same Eli as before he took that test and he is PERFECT. I know we will be getting creative with learning here too and that is just fine.:0) Love you guys!! Amy
hydra12 said…
I agree completely. Eli may have some learning issues, but he is not MR, and he does NOT have a low IQ.

Any decent teacher will look at a student, find out how he learns, and then adapt to his learning style. That's what teaching is. We learned that with Robert.

BTW, you should consider Paradise :-) Small school, close(or closer, anyway) to the metroplex, and some good teachers. They even have a great life skills program for Noah. Plus, the Intermediate School computer teacher is HOT! ;-)

Also, if you moved to Paradise, it might make figuring out where/when to have Christmas easier :-)
Recovering Noah said…
Mark, I'm going to interrupt right there and let everyone know that the Intermediate School Computer Teacher is your wife -and not YOU! Because everyone knows you do computers by day and preaching at night... so just wanted to clear up any potential confusion. Plus, that whole confusion thing would've been really gross considering you're my brother, KWIM? LOL

Paradise sounds like Paradise - but, boy, would it tick off Mom! :-)

Sandwich - I'm going to pick your brain for creative ideas. That belly button thing is awesome. You officially wear the title of Queen of Homeschool Creativity!

Amy - Can't wait to share ideas over the years. And can't wait to meet your kids. One more week before school is out and then we can meet the Fab Four!
hydra12 said…
Yeah, Beth said you'd take it that way. I almost told you that if you came to Paradise, I know of at least one church where you'd be welcome. Of course, I'm not exactly objective, because I'm in love with the youth minister's wife. The music minister's wife is pretty cute, too ;-)

Anyway, I wasn't trying to weird you out or anything - I'm just in a goofy mood.
Recovering Noah said…
LOL! No, you didn't weird ME out...I thought it was pretty funny.

Just wanted to add a point of clarification, though, to those who don't know that Beth now teaches computers. :-)
Anonymous said…
Hey Leslie,

You are right on track with this. How can anyone on this earth know from the results of a short test the intricacies of a human mind enough to label one's learning abilities. You will know more about Eli's learning abilities than any specialist ever will- no matter how many test they give him.

Labels are so dangerous. I've seen it happen and deviate a student's learning path in the public school setting several times over the last 11 years.

My Eli also has a unique learning style. Sometimes I think he is smarter than me, but of course at his first week of pre-school the teacher asks me if he is "slow". I didn't even know how to respond. I tried not to over-react or think poorly of the teacher. I assured her that he wasn't slow, but that he just has a unique way of learning. After a month now, they certainly realize that he can be a lot of things, but "slow" isn't one of them.

Leslie, being a technology coordinator now, I have access to some learning tools that might be of some use to you. I would love to help out. Shoot me an email if you want- fmsmitty@yahoo.com or fred@wickes.k12.ar.us.

Freddie
Kelly said…
You probably won't see this comment because its an older post, but I have these rants too.... I use a LOT of montessori and read a LOT of montessori in the home type blogs, and then I make a LOT of hands on activities from them to help all of my kids, but especially Abby (rt. hemi). I always get bugged when after our neuro psych has tested her, he wants to know what we want him to write to require the schools to get her some extra things - after we've explained we are all for her being in regular class. This year he offered to put her in pull-out PE - doesn't that sound fun - just Abby and a teacher while her class is doing something else. Let's not make her feel different or anything - even though she is on swim team, is learning to jumprope, etc. Ooops. Now I'm ranting on your blog. You're not alone. I'll start that school with you, but one of us has to move - and my kid has free OT/PT etc. so I'm not budging! Hang in there - you aren't alone.

Popular posts from this blog

The Answer to Noah's Shirt Chewing...

Acceptance and Moving Forward

Noah said, "I love you, Mom"!!!